Look Out Fans! NFL Players Gonna Get Your Mama!

Crime hysteria is as American as genetically modified apple pie. Whatever the rates of violent street crime in society, the existential threat of the black/brown youth predator can always be counted upon to repulse and titillate both the mass media and the popular consciousness. * The other all-consuming National Pastime centered on gawking at the black body in a spectrum of violence is the National Football League. Put these two together – crime hysteria and the NFL - and we have what can only be described as a cultural nocturnal emission.

Much ink has been spilled about the 29 - yes 29(!) - NFL players who have been arrested since the Super Bowl. At the center of all the coverage is former New England Patriots tight end Aaron Hernandez, accused of the pre-meditated execution of semi-pro football player Odin Lloyd. The details surrounding Lloyd’s murder get more ghastly by the day, but putting Hernandez’s photo at the center of a collage of the other 28 arrested players makes it seem like there is some kind of violent, to quote one site, “NFL Crime Wave.”  There is another serious case this off season of undrafted Cleveland Browns rookie Ausar Walcott who was arrested for attempted murder last Wednesday after punching a man outside of a New Jersey club. Outside of that, most of these 29 arrests revolve around domestic disputes, marijuana possession, driving while intoxicated, and even “drag racing”. I don’t want to make light about any of these issues [Except for the weed. I shall happily make light of that.] But attempts to create connective tissue between these incredibly disparate cases reeks of a highly racialized hysteria. You don’t have to be Cornel West to see the racial coding in articles like this one by Mark Madden that reads, “The Aaron Hernandez saga is hardly an isolated incident. It’s the latest chapter in pro football’s shameful litany. Gangsta culture perpetrating gangsta acts.” ** Then there is NFL Hall of Famer Fran Tarkenton on Fox & Friends, babbling,"We cannot let thugs and criminals into the locker room!"

All concerned should put down the smelling salts, stick the fainting couch back in the closet and deal with reality. First of all, there is no “NFL crime wave.” The 29 players, some who were not even on active rosters, constitute around 1% of all players vying for NFL roster spots. Also, in a study last December by Stephen Bronars, “NFL players are arrested about one-fourth as often as men age 22 to 34 in the general population…. The arrest rate for NFL players has averaged about 2.9% compared to 10.8% for men age 22 to 34 (based on FBI crime data by age for men in 2009).”

But let’s go deeper and talk more about this “nightmare” off-season. Most revolve around NFL players getting pulled over in their high-end automobiles and officers finding some form of contraband. They are getting caught in the gap between the privileges they believe will come with pro football fame and an increasingly all-encompassing criminal justice system that targets and warehouses masses of black and brown people at alarming rates. ***

The criminal justice system has changed, but the mentality of NFL jocks simply hasn’t caught up. If you hear stories about the NFL in the 1970s and 1980s, players were always just an autograph and a wink from having a police officer look the other way. Today we live in a surveillance society where there are speed cameras on every street, drug and gun-sniffing dogs at major train stations, and mandatory sentencing guidelines and a voracious for-profit prison industry. We are also living in the age of racial profiling where if you are a person of color and in a fancy car, you will draw more attention than Tim Tebow at the San Francisco Pride parade. Even without the fancy car, police harassment follows black and brown bodies in numbers unimaginable in those pre-9/11 days when we were all indignant about racial profiling for about an hour and a half. To take one example, n 2002, according to the ACLU, the police stopped New Yorkers 97,296 times. 80,176 were immediately released (82 percent). In 2012, New Yorkers were stopped by the police 532,911 times and in 473,644 cases were let go right away. In 87% of these cases, they were black or Latino.

Maybe what’s happening to NFL players is best understood as collateral damage of a US society addicted to arrests and a player’s culture where they expect privileges that no longer exist. This country jails more people than any nation on earth. We shouldn’t be surprised that NFL players have been caught in the undertow.  


* The mere fact that George Zimmerman’s defense of “I feared for my life, as I stalked this teenager with my gun” isn’t being laughed out of court is just more evidence of this.

** Let’s agree, internets, that unless your spellcheck is broken no more spelling gangster with an “a”.

*** What’s so fascinating about Michelle Alexander’s book “The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness” is not just it’s content, but the way it has connected with the experiences of millions of people across the country.

6 Reader Comments | Add a comment

Roger and DZ

DZ won't like the comparison but after reading his column, I could easily envision a PR person from Gooddell's office writing a similar piece. The PR flak and DZ would both strive to place the 29 arrests(I believe it's up to 31 now) in the context of society.

Sure the Hernandez case is just criminal but the other cases are not that bad. Where the PR statement would tone down the hysteria DZ adds a touch of color by the term "highly-racialized." DZ issues stats(2.9% vs. 10.8%) these would be echoed by the PR person.( A more revealing stat would how do the 29 arrests after the 2013 SB compare to previous SB's)

I also suspect the commish's office would deflect any discussion of a gangster NFL mentality by probably blaming an hysterical media for creating a sky-is-falling scenario. This compares with DZ deflecting the 29 arrests with a U.S. society addicted to arrests. See despite what DZ believes there is a common ground between him and Roger.

This is the conclusion you draw?

As with many stories, the reverse implication is actually even more interesting than the face value. Recently there is a media flourish about the NFL's police blotters, but consider this: If Aaron Hernandez were not connected to a first degree murder, if he were not a starter, or maybe even if he were on a team like Jacksonville, the other 28 arrests would have stayed in the background. Other than Hernandez's arrest, this offseason is pretty run of the mill for a the NFL, and would have been a yawn. If there is anything remarkable, it's that the NFL is nigh unstoppably popular, even with conservative white American audiences, despite the multiple, and sometimes gruesome, crimes.

Inconvenient though it may be, the NFL does have issues with crime. And the players involved usually are black. Not only does the NFL account for more run-ins with the law than Major League Baseball, the NBA, the NHL, or pro soccer, but many of the crimes involved guns, violence against women, and sometimes even a combination of both. Even excluding Hernandez's accusation, the NFL has graced us with one player who killed a pregnant girlfriend and carried her corpse in his trunk, one who fired a gun in a neighbor's ear and made him beg for his life, and yet another who allegedly shot a neighborhood man in a parked car in broad daylight. Is there any framework wherein behavior like this comes off as anything other than antisocial? Some may call institutional racism that law enforcement agents hassle black men for this kind of thing, but others might interpret it as professional competence.

What's more, the media coverage was so bellicose that most people reading this either forgot, or never knew about, the 3 incidents I mention above, to say nothing of some less sensational NFL offseason transgressions. All well and good being snarky about Mr. Menswarehousedude, but what does that have to do with the price of cheese in China? Some famous white creep disgraces himself, so just ignore this year's NFLonies?

Can't believe what I just read.

So Aaron, if one or a few black men commit a crime, then it's "professional competence" to assume all black men are criminals or potential criminals? Is it "professional competence" to make the same assumption about white men or men in general? I'll make it simple for you. It's not professional or competent, it's racist. That belief assumes that these men committed crimes because their skin is black and not because of their own personal experiences. That assumption is racist and ignorant.


No, it's professional competence to, you know, arrest the ones who do shoot a girlfriend, or pistol whipe a neighbor.


"Some may call institutional racism that law enforcement agents hassle black men for this kind of thing, but others might interpret it as professional competence. "

Don't know what country this person is referring to, but they ARE NOT hassling black men "for this kind of thing" they are, and have been, hassling black men for BEING BLACK for a VERY LONG TIME. This is so well documented it hardly needs mentioning.

Also, look at the statistics DZ cited, it should change your "argument."

P.S. Most mass murders are committed by white people, by a very large margin. And when white men commit murder we don't hear how their skin color, their maleness or their social class were contributing factors to their acts.

The dominant culture sees whites as individuals who's moral state reflects their individual will. White men kill simply because they are "sick" or "evil." When men of color murder its because they are those things but also because of factors uniquely attributable to their race.

Well said Leo M

Aaron's a fool. And a racist fool at that!

6 Reader Comments | Add a comment

PLEASE NOTE: This forum is for dialog between Edge of Sports readers. Discuss!

Submit your comment below:

Your Name


(Only if we need to contact you—not for advertising purposes)



Dave Zirin is the author of the book: "Welcome to the Terrordome: The Pain, Politics and Promise of Sports" (Haymarket). You can receive his column Edge of Sports, every week by going to dave@edgeofsports.com.
Become an Edge of Sports Sustainer (Click Here)

Contact him at edgeofsports@gmail.com