The NFL will remember 9/11 in all the wrong ways

Ten years ago, on the first Sunday after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, the NFL did something truly heroic and generous: nothing. The league willingly ate millions of dollars and cancelled the games out of respect for the unfolding tragedy. As 9/11 morphed into a decade-long “Global War on Terror”, the league has, to put it mildly, failed to show similar restraint. From the now ubiquitous presence of military flyovers and honor guards at every game, to the armed forces recruitment stations set up outside preseason contests, to having war-gourmands like General David Petraeus toss the coin before the Super Bowl, to staging Fox’s NFL pregame show from Bagram Airfield in Afghanistan (with Terry, Howie and the gang dressed in fatigues), the league has treated our era of endless war as an odious exercise in corporate branding.

This Sunday, the NFL season opens in earnest on the tenth anniversary of the September 11th attacks and the league, like John Boehner finding an abandoned pack of unfiltered smokes, just can’t control itself. Teams will be going all out to commemorate that horrific day ten years ago when 3000 people were killed in DC, Pennsylvania, and New York City. If you think this anniversary should be remembered with somber soft voices, and about as far away from a football game as possible, you are going to want to keep your distance from NFL Sunday or you will lose your lunch.

 

 NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell, on ESPN’s Mike and Mike in the Morning, said without a hint of humility, that the NFL will aim this Sunday to “help the country heal.” How will this healing take place? As the Associated Press reported, “Pregame tributes will be synchronized on CBS and Fox telecasts and shown on video boards in each stadium hosting games. Coaches, players and local first responders will hold field-length American flags for the playing of the national anthem.” The AP also reported that players, coaches and the sideline rabble will be compelled to wear a specially customized NFL 9/11 ribbon. The official “NFL 9/11 logo” will also be on the field of every game.

 

Roger Goodell’s office says that this pomp is aimed to "unite fans to recognize those who lost their lives, honor the families who lost loved ones, and salute the American spirit, the early responders on 9/11, and other heroes that contributed to the nation's recovery." If you are one of the 25 million Americans looking for work, or related to one of the hundreds of thousands of troops stationed overseas in three theaters of war, you might wonder what recovery Goodell is referencing.

 

The last decade has more resembled a sweat-soaked fever-dream than anything resembling a “recovery.” The statistics boggle the mind. More than 6,000 US troops have been killed. Over 550,000 soldiers have put in claims for disability. Among those unfortunate enough to have been born in the countries the US has invaded and occupied, the death toll has been estimated to be as much as one million lives lost. The current number of war refugees and displaced persons reaches almost eight million people. The economic cost to the United States has been estimated by Nobel Prize winning economist Joseph Stiglitz to be as  high as five trillion dollars. Now everyone in Washington DC is shocked that a decade of tax cuts and war has led to record deficits, and working people are told to "tighten our belts." It's been an awful decade of lies and loss, and its reality will go unacknowledged this Sunday.

 

 In all the scurrying to make sure “9/11 NFL Sunday” is a day to remember, one name is strikingly absent from the press release trumpeting the day’s events: Pat Tillman. After 9/11, Tillman took the extraordinary step of leaving the NFL to join the Army Rangers. His experiences in Iraq and Afghanistan pushed him to question the official rational for the Global War on Terror. He read anti-war authors. He told friends that he felt the war in Iraq was “f-in illegal.” Then he died at the hands of his fellow Rangers in an instance of what was deemed “friendly fire.” The Pentagon and the Bush administration hid this reality from Pat Tillman’s family. The NFL, for their part, inaugurated a USO center at Bagram Airfield in Pat Tillman’s name without hinting at the complicated realities of either Tillman’s service or his betrayal at the hands of those he trusted. The NFL’s failure to highlight Tillman in this Sunday’s 9/11 tributes is in some ways a relief but it also reads like an act of cowardice. His story is a polarizing one that Roger Goodell wants to avoid on this day of “unity.”

 

 But ten years from 9/11, unity is hardly the watchword of the moment. I spoke with Rory Fanning, the former U.S. Army Ranger, turned anti-war activist, who served with Pat and walked across the country in his memory. I asked Rory what he would like to see the NFL do to commemorate the decade anniversary since that fateful day. He said,  "I would ask the NFL for an hour of silence for the 100's of thousands killed after 9/11 in recognition of the criminally disproportionate response to that day.” If Roger Goodell must do something that sounds pretty dead-on. It certainly feels more right than the queasy mix of war, sport, and choreographed remembrance that Goodell has planned.

 

[Dave Zirin is the author of “The John Carlos Story” (Haymarket) and just made the new documentary “Not Just a Game.” Receive his column every week by emailing dave@edgeofsports.com. Contact him at edgeofsports@gmail.com.]

7 Reader Comments | Add a comment

stadium

Nice article, could you look into this mary koch and the vikings stadium issue?

zarin....


I applaud you for an article that actually has no mention/ influence of the high school kid mind set "you just saying that cause Im black"



I am also impressed that you give Pat Tillman his due respect.

RIP PT

Such a brave and honorable, man, an athlete and a thinker, exploited and wasted by the US army. Putting his story out there would make would-be recruit fans think twice. Can't have that!

Is there a right way to remember 9/11?

I do think that the 9/11 victims should be remembered. Whether the ceremony is loud or soft,long or short is immaterial.

I could easily dispense with the Star-Spangled Banner for all sporting events. It's just not needed.

I have less of a problem with military induction events before sporting events. Usually these are announced well in advance of the game. So if one is offended by this military swearing-in process just don't go to that particular game.

The Tillman tragedy is just that a tragedy.

Tillman

For this interested, particularly the person who commented that the "The Tillman tragedy is just that a tragedy", there's a documentary called The Tillman Story that you should check out.

Need FB/Twitter/G+ integration

RE the article: beautifully written. It has been a subject that has been in the back of my mind for a few years now but I have never been able to wrap a real..opinion, I guess...to it. I still don't think I have but this article is food for thought.

Also, may I suggest having the Facebook "Like" button and other social networking buttons on the blog? It just makes it that much easier to share your articles. If there is a reason for their absence, then all is well. Copying and pasting isn't too hard.

lies

After ten years of research and study, all I can say is that the entire 911 story is one huge lie.Many wonderful and innocent people have died, while those with blood stained hands go free.

7 Reader Comments | Add a comment

PLEASE NOTE: This forum is for dialog between Edge of Sports readers. Discuss!

Submit your comment below:

Your Name

Email

(Only if we need to contact you—not for advertising purposes)

Subject

Message

Dave Zirin is the author of the book: "Welcome to the Terrordome: The Pain, Politics and Promise of Sports" (Haymarket). You can receive his column Edge of Sports, every week by going to dave@edgeofsports.com.
Become an Edge of Sports Sustainer (Click Here)


Contact him at edgeofsports@gmail.com