All-Star Speak-Out: Baseball Players Pledge to Boycott Arizona All Star Game

If Major League Baseball’s 2011 All-Star Game is held as planned in the anti-immigrant “meth lab of democracy” otherwise known as Arizona, players are letting it be known that the show will go on without them. On Monday's media day for this week's 2010 game in Anaheim, several Latino All-Stars were asked for their thoughts about next year’s game taking place in a state being monitored by the justice department for racial profiling.

''If the game is in Arizona, I will totally boycott," said Milwaukee Brewers pitcher Yovani Gallardo. Kansas City reliever Joakim Soria and Detroit Tigers pitcher Jose Valverde seconded that emotion. ''They could stop me and ask to see my papers. I have to stand with my Latin community on this,” said Soria.


The three have now joined San Diego Padres all-star Adrian Gonzalez, and his teammates Yorvit Torrealba, and Heath Bell along with Chicago White Sox manager Ozzie Guillen in stating that they would stay away from Arizona next summer.

Other even more prominent players didn’t call for a boycott, but they made their feelings exceedingly clear. Major League home run leader, Toronto Blue Jays outfielder Jose Bautista said,  ''Hopefully, there are some changes in the law before [next year]. We have to back up our Latin communities.''

The biggest star in the game, Albert Pujols, came out in direct opposition to his Arizona-law-loving manager Tony LaRussa, saying, "I'm opposed to it. How are you going to tell me that, me being Hispanic, if you stop me and I don't have my ID, you're going to arrest me? That can't be.''

A spokesperson for the Baseball Players Association also made news by saying they would fully back any player who chose to boycott the 2011 game.  [As a side-note, Alex Rodriguez – Major League Baseball’s answer to Lebron James in too many ways to name – was also asked about Arizona’s laws but just said, ''Wrong guy,” and then pointed to other players in the locker room. Rodriguez then proceeded to drown after attempting to make love to his own reflection in a nearby duck pond.]

This flurry of commentary in this most staid of sports threatens to overshadow Tuesday’s Midsummer Classic and spotlight the political and moral impotence of Major League commissioner Bud Selig. Selig refused to comment on the issue today and his one statement all season on the issue managed to be both puzzling and inane. (After much analysis, it was determined that Selig wants the game to stay in Arizona.) Selig's constant crutch of no-comments may be coming to an abrupt end.

The sports media wasn’t asking about immigration out of concern for the 28% of Major Leaguers born outside the United States. They were probing the actual political thoughts of players because of a very real, growing movement of civil rights and grass roots organizations calling on MLB to move the game.

On Monday morning, the organization held a press conference where they showcased more than 100,000 names who had signed their petition calling on Major League Baseball to act. A protest has also been called for Tuesday at 3pm right at Angel Stadium, on all American Gene Autry Way in Anaheim.

As Wade Henderson, president of the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights and Janet Murguia is president of the National Council of La Raza wrote in an oped on Alternet, “Unless the league acts, next year our favorite all-stars could enter a hostile environment, and the families, friends and fans of a third of the players could be treated as second-class citizens because of their skin color or the way they speak…. We are not asking Selig to weigh in on immigration policy; we are asking him to take a stand against bigotry and intolerance. Despite being petitioned by numerous members of Congress and civil rights, labor and social justice groups, Selig has not adequately addressed the issue.”

He certainly has not. But if civil rights activists keep up the pressure on the outside and players keep speaking out on the inside, Selig will have no choice but to make perfectly clear where he stands on the most basic civil rights of his own players. If the NFL could move the Super Bowl from Arizona two decades ago because they wouldn’t acknowledge Martin Luther King’s birthday; if the NCAA can keep post-season tournaments out of states that still fly the confederate flag, then Bud Selig can wipe that hang-dog look off his face, straighten his back, and do the right thing.  If not for the people, he can do it for Pujols.


[Dave Zirin is the author of the forthcoming “Bad Sports: How Owners are Ruining the Games we Love” (Scribner) Receive his column every week by emailing Contact him at]

10 Reader Comments | Add a comment

In Bud we trust

In typical Bud Selig fashion I expect him to point to the Civil Rights game and profess his love for Jackie and Rachel Robinson to indicate MLB's commitment to Civil Rights. No, check that, he'll probably trot out Hank Aaron to say it for him. "Tricky Dick" Nixon didn't have anything on "Slick" Bud Selig.

Yeah Yovani...

Three cheers for Brewers pitcher Yovani Gallardo for being a young guy, still emerging as a pitcher, willing to speak out. His quote was a pleasant surprise in our local paper this morning. I already liked him as a pitcher now I like him more as a man too.

Reply to 'typical'

What an ass! What is it with you Ditto Heads? Your minds are on vacation, yet your mouths are busy working over time. Why do you feel the need to show the world how thoughtless, mean spirited, and cowardly you are. You always support the winning team to help you with the delusion that you are not losers. You have no sense of sportsmanship and you are a terrible waste of a lifeform!

Reply to 'typical'

What an ass! What is it with you Ditto Heads? Your minds are on vacation, yet your mouths are busy working over time. Why do you feel the need to show the world how thoughtless, mean spirited, and cowardly you are. You always support the winning team to help you with the delusion that you are not losers. You have no sense of sportsmanship and you are a terrible waste of a lifeform!


If he were alive today Barry Goldwater would be probably be this laws most vocal critic, but then again you and people of your ilk wouldn't even consider him to be a true conservative. Get your head clear; people on both the left and the right are against this law.


would probably be


Please learn to use proper spelling, spacing, punctuation, and capitalization before posting. Also, your most recent post is a loosely tied together collection of sentence fragments.


Gus like Bruce don't need to think about spelling and grammar because they are so used to exploiting their unearned privileges. Bruce probably used to pal around with W at Yale laughing about how they snorted their way through Vietnam.

History lesson for Bruce

Degrade baseball's contribution to civil rights? I wish they had made a contribution to degrade. Hiring Jackie Robinson was, as Malcolm X might say, like sticking a knife in someone, then pulling it out halfway and expecting to be praised. In the 18 years from 1947, when Jackie Robinson was hired, to 1965 when the Civil Rights Act was signed, baseball made zero contribution to the civil rights movement. Not to mention blacks were banned from baseball prior to 1947. Or that even white men were treated as chattel property by baseball until free agency was fought for and won in the 1970's. I hate to see Bud Selig and baseball rewrite and distort history for those who don't know.

good points CB

Excellent points, and one sees this kind of thing again and again. Whether its Lyndon Johnson signing Civil Rights legislation or Nixon and Ford claiming they got us out of Vietnam despite the obstructions of the anti-war community we shouldn't, in Tom Hayden's words, 'grab defeat from the jaws of victory.' It wasn't MLB that did anything but the actions of many individuals comitted to freedom and democracy who fought AGAINST entrenched powers and their institutions and won.

Also great reference to Malcolm, but we should also recall Bobby Seale, Huey Newton and Fred Hampton, "talkin' black power to black people, brown power to brown people, white power to workin' class and progressive white folk... I am...."

10 Reader Comments | Add a comment

PLEASE NOTE: This forum is for dialog between Edge of Sports readers. Discuss!

Submit your comment below:

Your Name


(Only if we need to contact you—not for advertising purposes)



Dave Zirin is the author of the book: "Welcome to the Terrordome: The Pain, Politics and Promise of Sports" (Haymarket). You can receive his column Edge of Sports, every week by going to
Become an Edge of Sports Sustainer (Click Here)

Contact him at