Anyone who believes that sports can’t be an effective platform for social justice, needed only to watch last night’s game between Los Suns of Phoenix and the San Antonio Spurs. The unprecedented decision by the entire Suns organization - from owner Robert Sarver to star players Amar'e Stoudamire and Steve Nash - to come out against Arizona’s anti-immigrant Senate Bill 1070, created a sports broadcast like no other in my lifetime. The game on TNT began with sideline reporter Marty Snider outside the arena covering a mushrooming 3,000 person civil rights march, led by Al Sharpton and Phoenix mayor Phil Gordon (both wearing Los Suns Jerseys.) Then the scene switched to the pre-game studio with host Ernie Johnson and former players Kenny “the Jet” Smith, Chris Webber, and Charles Barkley. The viewing audience then got an unexpected and bracing lesson in dissent.
Kenny Smith, like any good point guard, set up the others by saying, “I think it’s great that the team understands, the management understands and now the people of Phoenix are all rallying together at the same time.”
Barkley, a long time Arizona resident and a man who once said that he was a Republican until “the Republicans lost their damn minds” chimed in saying, “The only people screwing it up are the politicians. The Governor – the interim governor I might add - J.D. Hayworth and John McCain. They’re the ones screwing this thing up. I really take my hat off to Robert Sarver and the Suns for taking a stand. You know, living in Arizona for a long time, the Hispanic community, they’re like the fabric of the cloth. They’re part of our community and any time you try to do any type of racial profiling or racial discrimination……. President Obama you’ve got to do something because these lightweight politicians in Arizona have no idea what they are doing.”
The typically blunt Barkley speaking in such terms is hardly surprising. But it was Chris Webber who upped the ante, interrupting a visibly uncomfortable Ernie Johnson with, “Public Enemy said it a long time ago. ‘By the Time I Get to Arizona.’ I’m not surprised. They didn’t even want there to be a Martin Luther King day when John McCain was in [office.]. So if you follow history you know that this is part of Arizona politics.”
It was a remarkable display and it was difficult to not think of the millions of television viewers around the country, in sports bars, restaurants, and house parties, being confronted with this kind of forthright, plainspoken language.
But perhaps even more important than the support Los Suns received from protestors and broadcasters, was their play on the court. Phoenix trailed by nine at the end of the first quarter and Spurs star power forward Tim Duncan was scoring with ease. The crowd was dead and it wasn’t difficult to envision what would be said in the SportsWorld if Phoenix lost: “The political hoopla was a distraction.” “This is why sports and politics don’t mix.” “They should have been focused on the Spurs and not immigration.” And grinning smugly would have been LA Lakers coach Phil Jackson who chided the Suns yesterday saying, "If I heard it right the American people are really for stronger immigration laws.... I don't think teams should get involved in the political stuff."
In other words, everyone who stands with SB 1070 would be feeling a little more joyful this morning. It would have been an echo of the time Muhammad Ali lost his first fight to Joe Frazier and all the columnists and fans who wanted to see the draft dodging Ali punished, chortled gleefully after he was knocked to the canvas. But just when we were all ready to stick a fork in the brick-laying Suns, something remarkable happened. The slick shooting, fast breaking team started to crash the boards, play ugly, and do all the dirty work that wins games. Doughy, undersized three point shooter Jared Dudley started aggressively snatching offensive rebounds like his soul had been possessed by Barkley himself, energizing the crowd and shocking his
team back to life. The result was a 110-102 victory in which the run and gun Suns were held to just eight fast break points. Coach Alvin Gentry said afterward that he had never seen the team play so mentally tough.
Maybe this will be the start of a new trend where teams see the unifying benefits of going out on a political limb and taking a stand. Maybe players across the sports leagues who oppose SB 1070 will be inspired to come together in a common organization and demand Arizona cease the imposition of “Juan Crow” on the Latino population. Maybe the major sports unions, all of whom have voiced opposition to the bill, will release a joint statement saying that they will support any player or team who boycotts the state as long as SB 1070 is on the books. Maybe this is all utterly unrealistic. But it seems a hell of a lot more possible this morning than it did last night. Viva Los Suns.
Both on and off the court, Los Suns of Phoenix made one hell of a political statement against the San Antonio Spurs.
[Dave Zirin is the author of the forthcoming "Bad Sports: How Owners are Ruining the Games we Love" (Scribner) Receive his column every week by emailing dave@edgeofsports.com. Contact him at edgeofsports@gmail.com.]
Dave, for the last time, it's Amar'e Stoudemire -- not "Amare Stoudamire." They might look alike to you, but Amar'e is not Damon Stoudamire.
And since you have a cottage industry on this, remember: the President of Mexico is Felipe Calderon -- not "Ivan Calderon," the Puerto Rican outfielder.
It's apparently hard for Zirin to tell minorities apart.
Ivan,
You made your point in the previous column. Its clearly a mis-spelling on Dave's part. Yes it should be corrected if you are right, but no its not worth attempting to make him look bad.
You clearly have an agenda. Dave's is well known and documented, yours seems to be tearing people down that you dislike. Think about your actions.
John
While it would be nice to think that this might be the platform for the reintroduction of social activism into professional sports, I think we're a long ways from seeing players and definitely franchises from putting themselves out there.
Don't get me wrong, I'm glad the Suns did this and all but please note the wording of part of the press release that accompanied the announcement:
"The frustration with the federal government’s failure to deal with the issue of illegal immigration resulted in passage of a flawed state law."
In other words, we oppose the bill but we still want immigrants to get the hell out. OK, maybe that's overstating it, but at the very least, they're still trying not to ruffle those people who support discrimination against undocumented immigrants by claiming, "hey we still know that illegal immigrants are a problem" instead of taking a more principled stand and truly standing in solidarity with these people. And depsite all of the good will that they generate (which no doubt will help them with the latino market in arizona), this reduces what could have been a truly powerful statement into a PR stunt.
Hey Ivan the Terrible - Dave won't respond to your gibberish, nor should he, but your asinine attack is juvenile and the work of an obvious imbecile.
Nice try but your attempt at a gotcha is as deep as a baby pool - shallow.
Phil Jackson does the old "no politics" routine only after giving his populist stance. As if I needed any more reason to not like him. And keep treading on this, Phil, with your Latino fan base in LA.
Ivan, either you make a real point, or let it go. It's a typo (typographical error). The names are actually pronounced EXACTLY the same. Just stop.
Bob, if you're disapointed with the Suns gesture, get over it. My guess is you wanted something more like, "The Phoenix Suns, as an organization, call for the elimination of all borders." I would've loved that, but it's a friggin' NBA team. How about, "Nice gesture. I'd like to see more."
I don't expect the Suns to throw all resources towards the issue, but their statement decouples the law from the general issue of racist immigrant rhetoric to which it is inextricably entwined.
I'm not mad at them,and i'm very glad they did it. But if they're going to make a half-assed statement, I'm only going to half-assed applaud them for it.
Love the message they are trying to send, it's sad that my San Antonio Spurs have to come back and end the Sun's season.
Great piece...Now let's hope Bud Selig pulls the All-Star game out of Arizona.
Amar'e changed his name from Amare in fall of 2008. Apologies for not having this down correctly. The idea that this was done with racist intent is to put it mildly laughable.
Until reading this column, I had no idea Phil Jackson said anything so specific about Los Suns' stance, immigration, or what the American people supposedly want. As a lifetime Lakers fan, I find his comments disgusting considering the Latino fanbase the team has here in SoCal. With that kind of attitude, I don't care how many rings that guy has, he can take his bloated contract and walk next year.
When Phil Jackson was a second-stringer for the Knicks he was indeed very political. He was a staunch antiwar guy, tossed away his parent's establishment Christianity, and was clearly embracing the social revolution of the 60s.
As corroborated by a CBS News/60 Minutes article:
"By the time he got to the NBA in 1967, he had become a Buddhist. He was the NBA's resident flower child, a rebel who grew his hair long and protested the Vietnam war."
It's an old and tired story when athletes and their Neanderthal fans wet their pants about keeping sports and politics separate. It's absolute gibberish. As soon as they strike up the war-mongering Star Spangled Banner, and fly over their machines of death and destruction, and honor their fallen warriors (read: state sponsored terrorists), and finally sing "God Bless America," they have stamped their political ticket. They are part of the body politic.
In fact, most American sporting events are goddamn political rallies - propaganda with a side of beer and peanuts.
It's not the politics they challenge, it's the type of politics they don't like... it's the dissent of the establishment's status quo dogma.
As long as the political views "goose-step" with the corporate/Washington consensus, it's God Bless America.
Cue Kate Smith.
When Phil Jackson was a second-stringer for the Knicks he was indeed very political. He was a staunch antiwar guy, tossed away his parent's establishment Christianity, and was clearly embracing the social revolution of the 60s.
As corroborated by a CBS News/60 Minutes article:
"By the time he got to the NBA in 1967, he had become a Buddhist. He was the NBA's resident flower child, a rebel who grew his hair long and protested the Vietnam war."
It's an old and tired story when athletes and their Neanderthal fans wet their pants about keeping sports and politics separate. It's absolute gibberish. As soon as they strike up the war-mongering Star Spangled Banner, and fly over their machines of death and destruction, and honor their fallen warriors (read: state sponsored terrorists), and finally sing "God Bless America," they have stamped their political ticket. They are part of the body politic.
In fact, most American sporting events are goddamn political rallies - propaganda with a side of beer and peanuts.
It's not the politics they challenge, it's the type of politics they don't like... it's the dissent of the establishment's status quo dogma.
As long as the political views "goose-step" with the corporate/Washington consensus, it's God Bless America.
Cue Kate Smith.
When the so-called minority speak up, we tend to find that they really weren't the minority. I am Canadian and we are all proud of Steve Nash up in the Great White North. But, when we see positions of integrity taken by inclusive Americans, we are also a little more proud to be part of the North American community
Dave,
You fixed the Amar'e part, but not the Stoudamire part. Ivan was pretty clear, it's Stoudemire, not Stoudamire (as in Damon).
Unlike Ivan though I don't think you're racist.
PLEASE NOTE: This forum is for dialog between Edge of Sports readers. Discuss!
Dave Zirin is the author of the book: "Welcome to the Terrordome: The Pain, Politics and Promise of Sports" (Haymarket). You can receive his column Edge of Sports, every week by going to dave@edgeofsports.com.
Become an Edge of Sports Sustainer (Click Here)
Contact him at edgeofsports@gmail.com
Please consider making a donation to keep this site going.
Become an Edge of Sports Sustainer (Click Here)